The Rookie Challenge

Rookie Challenge

In his Rookie Challenge preview, David Thorpe said: “If Rose didn’t have to fly in after his Thursday night game, I’d expect him to dominate much of the action with his dribble-attack game. Or his improved midrange game. Plus his acrobatic finishes at the rim. But since he plays so many minutes for the Bulls, and this game is essentially a back-to-back for him, there’s a chance he’ll chill and let his teammates do the fun stuff.”

Thorpe was right on the money. Rose played fewer minutes than any Rookie starter (20:34). He had a team-high 7 assists — and only Rodney Stuckey of the Sophomore team had more (with 9) — but scored only 4 points on 1-for-5 shooting. He never looked to force the action or assert himself on offense. (Defense isn’t played in the Rookie Challenge, unless by accident.) Most of the time, he was content to bring the ball up and pass it off as soon as he reached the three-point arc.

According to K.C. Johnson of the Chicago Tribune, Rose didn’t sleep overnight and got only three hours of sleep on his 6 a.m. flight. So sure, he was tired. But fellow rook Michael Beasley was in pretty much the same boat, having played (and played big) in the Heat’s Thursday night win over the Bulls in Chicago. Beasley, however, scored a Rookie team-high 29 on 11-for-22 shooting. In fact, only Kevin Durant of the Sophomore team put up more points (a rookie-sophomore record 46 on 17-for-25).

Of course, Thorpe predicted that too: “Beasley might be thrilled at the chance to show off his offensive game without being in D-Wade’s shadow. Although on the Heat he’s just another guy, he’s a very respected talent on this team.” That dude must have a time machine or something.

Overall, the Rookie Challenge is pretty meaningless, so I don’t want to make too much out of Rose’s performance. But the one thing that often worries me about Derrick is his “quiet leader” mentality. He doesn’t always have the hard edge/killer instinct that you typically see in the all-time greats. Despite the limited sleep and general lack of importance in the game, I would have liked to see him assert himself against his closest peers and rookie rivals like Beasley.

Bonus quotage: Here’s what Rose had to say about the game: “It was fun. The crowd got me into it even though I wasn’t really producing. Just being a part of it was amazing. I just want to have fun and watch how players react to certain things. Watch LeBron [James] — he’s my favorite player — and see how he acts toward fans and media. I never thought I’d be here. You think about playing in the NBA, but you never think about playing in the All-Star Game. For me to have this opportunity, it’s a blessing. Hopefully, one day I can be playing with the big boys.”

Extras: Recap, Box Score, TrueHoop Live Blog, Hollinger Rookie Grades, Hollinger Sophomore Grades. And here are the game highlights:

, , , ,

4 Responses to The Rookie Challenge

    Detroit Murder Dog February 14, 2009 at 8:36 pm #

    Rose and Beasley were not in the same boat. Beasley got to Phoenix shortly after the Bulls-Heat game, so he got a full night’s sleep. Just a small point, but still…

    PT from Oaktown February 15, 2009 at 12:06 am #

    I see Rose, resting, so he can play well in the games that really count. He is a winner who cares how he plays in some rookie challenge.

    Latin_D February 16, 2009 at 12:53 am #

    I guess it makes sense, but still, I wish the players gave it their all. Durant was a pleasure to watch, and he’s really come along this year. I think this was the most interesting Rooks/Sophs game I’ve watched in many years.

    What did you think of Durant?


  1. The Skills Challenge » By The Horns - February 15, 2009

    […] I sort of criticized his casual approach to the Rookie Challenge, but this made up for it. And Rose’s unshakably calm demeanor was definitely a bonus. He never seemed nervous or under pressure. Derrick: You have a place on my Trivial Pursuit team any day. […]

Designed by Anthony Bain